|
|
||||||||
a UGG Ltd., Morden, MB Canada R6M 1C2
b Dep. of Plant Sciences and Crop Development Centre, Univ. of Saskatchewan, 51 Campus Dr., Saskatoon, SK, Canada S7N 5A8
c Dep. of Plant Sciences, Montana State Univ., Bozeman, MT, USA 59717-3140
d Dep. of Plant Agriculture, Univ. of Guelph, Guelph, ON, Canada N1G 2W1
e Retired, Soils and Crops Research and Development Center, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, Sainte Foy, QC Canada G1V 2J3
f Crops and Livestock Research Centre, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, Charlottetown, PE, Canada C1A 4N6
g Lacombe Research Centre, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, Lacombe, Alberta, Canada T4L 1W1
h Retired, British Columbia Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Fisheries Food Industry Branch, Dawson Creek, BC, Canada V1G 4J2
i Dep. of Soil and Crop Sciences, Colorado State Univ., Fort Collins, CO, USA 80523-1170
* Corresponding author (hucl{at}sask.usask.ca)
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Abbreviations: BKG, genetic background CWRS, Canada Western Red Spring EXP, experiment PI, photoperiod insensitive response type PPD, photoperiod response type PS, photoperiod sensitive response type
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Research conducted in Europe and North America indicates that (i) plant development patterns in wheat generally differ between PS and PI types and (ii) environmental conditions for a particular location, year, or geographical area can contribute to the yield advantage of one photoperiod type over the other. In Europe, PI cultivars, all likely carrying Ppd-D1, were shown to have a 30% yield advantage over PS cultivars in southern regions, 15% in mainland regions, and no yield advantage in the UK (Worland et al., 1994; Worland 1996). In all environments, Ppd-D1 tended to accelerate heading and maturity, reduce tillering, reduce plant height, and reduce spikelets per spike. Increased spikelet fertility compensated for the shortened life cycle and reduced tillering and spikelet number. Interestingly, the environmental conditions prevailing during the period from grain set to maturity had a significant effect on grain yield. In southern and mainland Europe, PI cultivars benefited from the hot and dry summers as these early genotypes were able to fill their grain before the hot desiccating summer conditions. In the UK, PS cultivars performed best in their traditional cool damp summers as the extended grain filling period allowed later flowering genotypes to produce larger grains and higher yields. In contrast, PI cultivars performed best in the non-traditional warmer, drier summers that sometimes occur in the UK. Thus, the Ppd-D1 allele aids PI cultivars in avoiding the heat stress within consistent and variable environments. Heat and moisture stresses during grain filling have been associated with abortion of tillers and reduced kernel weight in wheat (Fischer and Maurer, 1976; Musick and Dusek, 1980). Moisture stress before anthesis and at maturity has reduced grain yield, seeds per spike, and kernel weight in wheat (Entz and Fowler, 1988). Currently, most wheat varieties grown in southern and mainland Europe are PI because of their wider adaptation, relative to PS cultivars, while varieties in the UK are mostly PS (Foulkes et al., 2004).
Photoperiod genes have a direct influence on photosynthetic potential and components of yield (Muira and Worland, 1994). For example, Pugsley (1965)(1966) reported that delays in maturity with PS genotypes caused an increase in both leaf and spikelet numbers. Wall and Cartwright (1974) reported that PS lines were later heading and produced a greater number of spikelets per spike. In North America, two reports have concluded that the PI trait could be used without agronomic penalty in the spring wheat growing region of the USA (Busch et al., 1984; Marshall et al., 1989). Busch et al. (1984) compared the performance of 10 near-isogenic hard red spring wheat pairs derived from two crosses over three environments in Minnesota. For grain yield averaged over years, PI lines were equal to PS lines at one location and higher yielding than PS lines at two locations by an average of 9%. Marshall et al. (1989) compared the performance of near-isogenic PI and PS hard red spring wheat lines derived from 11 different parents in the upper midwestern USA (4448°N). Generally, this comparison indicated that PI lines were (i) earlier to head (2.5 d); (ii) earlier to ripen (1.0 d); (iii) longer in grain-filling period (1.4 d); (iv) 3% higher yielding (91 kg ha1); (v) lower in protein (2 g kg1); (vi) shorter (27 mm); and (vii) similar in test weight. In all parental backgrounds and environments tested, PI lines yielded as high as or higher than PS lines.
In Canada, Knott (1986) reported that limited research had been conducted on the Canadian prairies with respect to the agronomic effect of incorporating photoperiod insensitivity into locally adapted cultivars. Knott (1986) compared the performance of near-isogenic PI and PS hard red spring wheat lines derived from one cross in Saskatoon, SK (52°N) and Elrose, SK (51°N) in a 2-yr study. Sensitive lines significantly out-yielded PI lines by an average of 2.1%. An important consideration for determining the effect of photoperiodism on spring wheat is the range of latitudes tested. Lebsock et al. (1973), Busch and Chamberlain (1981), Busch et al. (1984), Marshall et al. (1989), and Knott (1986) used test locations within a relatively small geographical area within the upper midwestern USA or Canada. To date, research studying the effect of photoperiod on the agronomic performance of spring wheat over a broad range of environments within Canada is lacking. In the present study, spring wheat lines near isogenic for photoperiod response were tested over a wide range of latitudes from Colorado and Montana to the northern edge of western Canada's grain belt. The objective of the study was to compare the agronomic performance of near-isogenic PS and PI hard red spring wheat lines over 21 environments in 1996 to 1998 to determine the effect of photoperiod response on agronomic traits at the higher latitudes of North America.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Forty-eight lines, including sensitive (n = 8) and insensitive (n = 8) lines from each of the three genetic backgrounds, were evaluated in 21 field experiments over 3 yr (19961998). The experimental design was a randomized complete block design (RCBD) with three replications. Twenty-one station-years of field data collected from 10 locations in 1996 to 1998 were used to evaluate the photoperiod response of spring wheat. In 1996, the lines were tested at five locations (Bozeman, MT [45.40°N 111.00W]; Guelph, ON [43.34°N 80.16W]; Ste. Foy, QC [46.47°N 71.18W]; Saskatoon, SK [52.10°N 106.40W], and Elrose, SK [51.12°N 108.01W]). In 1997, testing was conducted at an additional five locations, including Akron, CO (40.09°N 103.13W); Charlottetown, PE (46.14°N 63.09W); Dawson Creek, BC (55.44°N 120.15W); Elgin, MB (49.26°N 100.15W); and Fort Vermillion, AB (58.22°N 115.59W). In 1998, testing was conducted at six locations (Bozeman, MT; Saskatoon, SK; Elrose, SK; Charlottetown, PEI; Elgin, MB; and Fort Vermillion, AB). The expansion of sites in 1997 and 1998 provided a broader range of latitudes and growing conditions. Individual plots consisted of four rows 3.0 m long at Bozeman, MT; six rows 3.0 m long at Guelph, ON; four rows 3.0 m long at Ste. Foy, QC; four rows 3.6 m long at Saskatoon and Elrose, SK; four rows 4.8 m long at Akron, CO; four rows 3.0 m long at Charlottetown, PE (rows spaced 0.2 m apart); six rows 5.0 m long at Dawson Creek, BC; four rows 3.6 m long at Elgin, MB; and four rows 7.0 m long at Fort Vermillion, AB. Rows were spaced 0.3 m apart unless otherwise specified. Plots were sown at a rate of 250 seeds m2. Seeds were treated with the systemic fungicide Vitavax Single Solution (Uniroyal Chemical Ltd., Elmira, ON; active ingredient carbathiin) at the recommended rate. Fertilizer was drilled in with the seed at recommended rates to supply sufficient levels of N-P-K. Eleven traits were measured, but not all traits were measured in each environment. Number of leaves on the main stem was determined as described by Wang et al. (1995). Data were collected for days to heading (50% spike emergence), days to maturity (95% physiological maturity), and plant height. At maturity, 10 spikes were collected from the upper canopy of each plot to determine spikelets per spike, seeds per spike, and yield per spike. Plots were combine-harvested at maturity and grain samples were dried with forced air driers. Data were collected on grain yield and 1000-kernel weight.
Statistical analyses were conducted by Minitab Version 12 (Minitab Inc, State College, PA). The structured treatment design used in the field study was a factorial design with two photoperiod response types, three genetic backgrounds, and eight lines within each photoperiod and background. For ANOVAs, the statistical model included sources of variation due to experiment (EXP), replication within EXP, photoperiod response type (PPD), genetic background (BKG), lines within PPD and BKG, and all interactions among EXP, PPD, and BKG. Experiment represents the testing at individual sites in individual years. Experiment, replication, and experimental line were considered random effects. Genetic background and photoperiod response type were fixed effects. Bartlett's test (P = 0.05) was used to test for the homogeneity of variances. Average differences between photoperiod response types were tested for significance at 0.05 and 0.01 by paired t tests.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
Nonsignificant photoperiod response type x genetic background interactions (PPD x BKG) were observed for all 11 traits, except for fertile spikelets per spike and seeds per spike (Table 1). Significant non-crossover PPD x BKG interactions were observed for fertile spikelets per spike and seeds per spike. The interactions were significant because of changes in the magnitude of the response of PPD across BKG. The interactions were noncrossover because the ranking of PPD remained constant across BKG (Baker, 1988). For fertile spikelets per spike, significant changes in magnitude occurred between PPD across CDC Makwa (0.7 spikelets) and SWP5304 (0.6 spikelets) backgrounds (Table 3), indicating that PS lines had consistently more fertile spikelets per spike relative to PI lines as shown in Table 2. For seeds per spike, significant differences between PPD indicated that the PS lines had consistently more seeds per spike, relative to PI lines, within the CDC Makwa background (1.4 seeds per spike) (Table 3). Only crossover interactions are of a concern to plant breeders (Baker, 1988), and thus within this study, as a significant crossover PPD x BKG interaction would have indicated that the PPD changed in ranking or were instable across BKG for a given trait.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Averaged over all environments tested, PS lines out-yielded PI lines by 170 kg ha1 or 4.9% (n = 20 environments). A preliminary ANOVA analysis indicated that the PS-PI differences in grain yield among sites were not significantly related to latitude (P = 0.16; data not shown). The increase in grain yield of the PS near-isogenic lines likely resulted, at least in part, from delayed heading and an increase in total spikelets per spike and fertile spikelets per spike (Table 2). Rawson (1971) also reported that later heading was associated with higher spikelets per spike and grain yield. Marshall et al. (1989) suggested that the photoperiod response by temperature interaction had a large influence on grain yield. Busch and Chamberlain (1981) and Worland (1996) reported that the avoidance of stress at key plant development times could be important in affecting potential grain yield. Weather data was not available in our present study and, thus, the avoidance of stress at key plant development times by PS lines may or may not have provided sensitive types with a yield advantage over PI lines. Further research is needed in the higher latitudes of North America to determine if the Ppd-B1 and Ppd-A1 alleles, in near-isogenic lines derived from diverse genetic backgrounds, result in a lower yield penalty relative to that imposed by the Ppd-D1 allele in our present study.
In Canada, research into the agronomic benefit of photoperiod insensitivity in wheat is very limited. In western Canada, approximately 28% of currently grown CWRS cultivars have been classified for photoperiod response. Out of the 25 currently grown CWRS cultivars, five are PI (CDC Teal, Hughes and Hucl, 1993; AC Eatonia, de Pauw et al., 1994; AC Elsa, Clarke et al., 1997; AC Intrepid, de Pauw et al., 1999; AC Abbey, de Pauw et al., 2000) while two are described as PS (AC Barrie, McCaig et al., 1996; AC Cadillac, de Pauw et al., 1998). The photoperiod response of the remaining 18 CWRS cultivars has not been described in the literature. Currently, the diversity of PI alleles within Canadian PI cultivars is unclear. Cao et al. (2002) reported that AC Minto and CDC Makwa were closely related based on their Neepawa-involved pedigree (genetic similarity coefficient = 0.80). Wheat cultivars within the Neepawa-involved pedigree subgroup (n = 12) were most related to five cultivars sharing North Dakota germplasm (similarity coefficient = 0.67) and least related to two cultivars which shared CIMMYT-based (Mexico) pedigrees (similarity coefficient = 0.56). Caution must be taken when extrapolating the results within this study to other related or unrelated genetic backgrounds grown in the higher latitudes of North America because the PI trait is currently carried by some CWRS wheat cultivars without agronomic penalty. For example, AC Intrepid (PI) out-yields AC Barrie (PS) by 5% in the central region of Saskatchewan, Canada (Saskatchewan Agriculture, Food, and Rural Revitalization, 2003). At this point, it is premature to make any general recommendations to spring wheat breeders in northern USA and Canada to switch from the PI to the PS trait within their breeding programs. Further research is needed assessing (i) PI and PS near-isogenic lines derived from different genetic backgrounds and (ii) PI near-isogenic lines carrying different PI alleles in multiple and diverse geographical regions within the higher latitudes of North America. Collectively, this research may or may not show that the Ppd alleles, conferring photoperiod insensitivity, are detrimental to grain yield in spring wheat grown in the northern areas of North America.
To date, Canadian research suggests that PS lines are generally higher yielding than PI lines when grown in the higher latitudes of North America. In contrast, Busch et al. (1984) and Marshall et al. (1989) reported that the PI trait could be used without agronomic penalty in the spring wheat growing region of the USA, indicating that further research is needed to determine at which latitude or geographical region the PI genotypes out-perform PS types. In the higher latitudes of North America, the agronomic trade-off appears to be a 2- to 3-d delay in heading and maturity. The risk of grade-loss due to early frost should be balanced against delayed maturity in the northern edge of western Canada's grain belt. The significance of discovering further genes and regulatory pathways controlling flowering and maturity in spring wheat may allow plant breeders to create cultivars with increased environmental adaptability. With regard to breeding for appropriate maturity, genetic loci influencing flowering and development time could be incorporated into backgrounds that carry sensitivity to photoperiod. Earliness per se could also be used directly to influence time to heading in cultivars carrying sensitivity to photoperiod (Hoogendoorn, 1985; Worland, 1996). Chromosome mapping and markers associated with photoperiod, vernalization and earliness genes are becoming increasingly useful as cultivars are tailored to specific environments (Ben Amer et al., 1997; Sourdille et al., 2000).
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
Received for publication November 4, 2003.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. D. Sherman, D. K. Weaver, M. L. Hofland, S. E. Sing, M. Buteler, S. P. Lanning, Y. Naruoka, F. Crutcher, N. K. Blake, J. M. Martin, et al. Identification of Novel QTL for Sawfly Resistance in Wheat Crop Sci., December 30, 2009; 50(1): 73 - 86. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
N. K. Blake, S. P. Lanning, J. M. Martin, M. Doyle, J. D. Sherman, Y. Naruoka, and L. E. Talbert Effect of Variation for Major Growth Habit Genes on Maturity and Yield in Five Spring Wheat Populations Crop Sci., June 26, 2009; 49(4): 1211 - 1220. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. J. Willenborg, E. C. Luschei, A. L. Brule-Babel, and R. C. Van Acker Flowering Phenology and Synchrony between Volunteer and Cropped Spring Wheat: Implications for Pollen-Mediated Gene Flow Crop Sci., May 11, 2009; 49(3): 1029 - 1039. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Iqbal, A. Navabi, R.-C. Yang, D. F. Salmon, and D. Spaner The Effect of Vernalization Genes on Earliness and Related Agronomic Traits of Spring Wheat in Northern Growing Regions Crop Sci., May 31, 2007; 47(3): 1031 - 1039. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| The SCI Journals | Agronomy Journal | Vadose Zone Journal | |||
| Journal of Natural Resources and Life Sciences Education |
Soil Science Society of America Journal | ||||
| Journal of Plant Registrations | Journal of Environmental Quality |
The Plant Genome | |||